On this day, October 21, six years ago, a child was born. He was small, no bigger than the palm of a small woman’s hand, weighing slightly more than a few feathers. His entrance to the world was too soon, too abrupt, unexpected.
He fought to live.
On this day, October 21, four years ago, a different child died. He too was small for his almost five years, weighing no more than a few good sized rocks. His departure from this world was too soon, too abrupt, unexpected.
His fight for life was over.
I’ve written and rewritten this post over in my head from the moment I learned Jumby’s birthday fell on Shalebug’s death day early on in the adoption process.
Each time I stop, having run into a wall of emotion that is too tall to climb. So I pushed it out of my head, and out of my reality, telling myself I would deal with this mix of emotions tomorrow.
Tomorrow became today and there is no pushing it out of my mind.
There is a little boy, who for the first time in his life, has a forever family to celebrate his birthday with.
There is a little boy, who will no longer have birthdays to celebrate.
We were prepared for the emotional impact of bringing in a new life to our family. As a family we talked at length to each other, to ourselves what it would mean to love another little boy in the absence of another. We knew there would be nothing that could fill the void Bug’s death created, no amount of love or time could fill the vacuum created with his absence.
Like the world around us, we knew we needed to move on, to continue, to live. We knew instinctively the only way to heal would to be to keep loving. Jumby has been the miracle medicine this family has so direly needed for so long. This is a family that is meant to share, to embrace and we knew that another child, another sibling was out there waiting for us to find and call our own.
The love he freely gives us with each laugh, each hug continues to soothe the raw edges of our wounds of grief.
But today, on the day of Jumby’s birth and Shale’s death, it is a cruel reminder of what we have all lost.
Perhaps it won’t always be this difficult. Perhaps I’m being too hard on myself, holding myself to higher expectations than any mother can possibly maintain. But I don’t know how to do this. I don’t know how to wish one son a happy birthday while not remembering how his brother turned cold and blue in my arms.
It feels like a knife through our love. A betrayal to Shale for trying to find joy on the day he was ripped away from us. A betrayal to Jumby for not being able to wish him a happy birthday without wiping silent tears that streak down our cheeks.
My children are struggling with this. They don’t know how to cope, how to comprehend, how to compartmentalize their pain alongside their love for their new brother. They look at me with wounded eyes and cry softly wondering if Shale will think they are abandoning him for a live sibling. They weep while wondering if they are betraying this new brother for feeling sadness on a day that should be laced with nothing but joy for the birth of their Jumby.
I’m struggling with this. Deep inside me I worry if Shale is aware of this, if he thinks I’ve forgotten him for my new son. I worry Jumby will question every cuddle I give him, wonder if I’m nuzzling the soft underside of his neck while wishing it was a different little boy in my arms.
It’s complicated and absurd and the irony makes me cackle out loud like a crazy lady inside a padded room.
I can’t change the past, I can’t undo death, nor rearrange time to make birthdays unto their own, unmarred by the fog of loss. I can only wrap the love of my little boys around my heart and put one foot in front of the other while hoping desperately that the example I’m setting is not doing more harm than good.
Today, on October 21, I sit here and marvel how six years ago, my child was born and I never even knew it. A boy who should never have had the strength to live a day has somehow managed to live 2190 days and counting. My beautiful son with dimples so deep you can lose yourself in them.
Today, on October 21, six years ago, our family was given the greatest gift we have ever known, even if we didn’t know it then. A fourth son, a brother who can’t stand or speak or see yet somehow has the ability to allow us to soar to heights of love we had all forgot was even possible.
Today, on October 21, I sit here and remember how four years ago, I said goodbye to my boy and sang to him his last lullaby. A boy who lived longer than anyone thought possible but not nearly long enough for those who loved him. My beautiful son with his bright blue eyes and lashes that touched the sky.
Today, on October 21, four years ago, our family endured the greatest loss we have ever known, a pain we never knew existed. A son, a brother who couldn’t talk, or eat or smile yet somehow had the ability to show us the meaning of unconditional love as he gave us enough love to last a life time.
I will light a candle for one son while I help another blow out his own as he makes a wish.
Today I will gather all my children around and hold them dear to my heart and know that no matter what the day is, whether a birthday or an anniversary, it is a day to celebrate the heart. No matter how fractured it is, the pieces will always expand to love another.
I love you both so very much, my beautiful boys.

Happy Birthday Jumby. We love you so very much.
(Identity concealed to appease the governmental gods while the adoption is finalized.)

We remember Bug. Always and forever we love you little man.






Ashley, The Accidental Olympian
Tears well up in my eyes and all I can think to say is… actually, there are no words to truly convey my sympathy.
What a sad, yet equally amazing day. I wish your family only the best.
thepsychobabble
what a beautiful post. FWIW I would bet money that both of your boys know how very much you love them, and I doubt Bug would hold any grudge over you guys celebrating Jumby’s birthday.
Cat
((hugs)) to you & your family!! You’re in my prayers. Happy Birthday to Jumby!!
Amy @ Muddy Boots
I didn’t realize (or maybe I’d forgotten) that we lost our boys so close together. My Nathaniel died Oct 19th, 2005. He died shortly after birth, so the circumstances were different, but I know that heart fracturing, earth shattering, unimaginable loss.
Hugs.
andrea bent
that was beautiful! im sorry for you losss!love and hugs to you and your beautiful family at such an emotional time!
sweetsalty kate
No matter what you believe, our elsewhere children return to that one energy and become something else entirely, something not remotely saddled with all the attachments of being human. Like guilt, or feelings of abandonment, or jealousy, or regret.
He knows your love no matter what day it is. He knows love, and he is love.
xo
(Happy birthday, Jumby. Cake on yer face.)
Brenda
First of all, I was struck by the very strange coincidence that today is also my son’s birthday and reading your post made my heart hurt.
Although I cannot begin to comprehend the cosmic mix of pain and joy that is in your heart today, I do believe the love we feel for new people who come into our lives never diminishes the love we feel for people who have passed through and from our lives. A new love is not a betrayal but a living testament to the loved ones who are gone. We somehow believe that we must grieve long and hard for those we loved, and the longer and harder we grieve, the more it proves how much we loved them. But you must know Bug has no doubt about your love or devotion to him. You don’t have to prove that to him.
So, please light the candles, send up an “I love you” to Bug, and celebrate two lives today with no guilt, only joy for the precious family you have been blessed with. And HAPPY BIRTHDAY, JUMBY!
Will
Love is the greatest power we know. Your love for your children makes you one of the most powerful women I know. All my love Cancadian.
Stimey
My heart goes out to you. Your Bug would never think that you’ve forgotten him or tried to replaceme him. Never. Your love for him is so evident. Bug would be so happy that you have some joy on this very difficult day. Happy Birthday, Jumby! You’ve found yourself a wonderful family!
Sincerely, Jenni
I just found your blog today, thanks to Avitable.
I cannot imagine what you are going through, and I won’t pretend to. You have so much love and affection in your heart and soul, there is no way either son could question your feelings. You sound like a great mom, and I am very sorry for your loss.
sweetsalty kate
(that comment’s not meant to be taken in a religious context. It could be. But it doesn’t have to be. I’m kinda squirrelly that way. Squirrels are cool. Justin calls them rats with good P.R., but hey. They are, at least, inclusionary free thinkers.)
becky @therealbecks
happy birthday jumby. and i’m so sorry about shale. this was beautifully written. thanks for sharing your heart.
Jessi
My daughter’s due date was on my son’s death date. I nearly worried myself into an early grave that she would be born (against all odds) and that terrible, terrible day. I can’t imagine what it would be like. My heart and thoughts are with you.
René
Wishing the happiest of birthdays for your Jumby. I’m so glad he has your family. Your Bug was – IS – an absolute beauty.
Blessings for all of you.
MFA Mama
Damn, Tanis. You weren’t kidding when you labeled this one “tear-jerker.” I am bawling. You are amazing. You are a damned fine writer. Wow. I was already more than a little in awe of you but now it’s more like you’re my hero. You are so emotionally intelligent and eloquent in expressing all of this, making the most sense of it you can, and I agree with every word you wrote. It’s definitely a day to celebrate the heart, the good and the painful of it, and think first and foremost about the love. Love for Bug, love for “Jumby,” love to soothe and heal you and your older kids and Boo. You guys are gonna be okay. I’m thinking of you. And I’m burning a candle too. Jews do that, you know. It’s called a yahrzeit. You light it on the anniversary of a loved one’s death, to honor them. Mine is a Yankee Candle that smells good, and I see it and smell it and think of your Bug. He was a beautiful little guy, and as terrible as his death was you have moved forward with such love that even though I don’t personally believe in an afterlife, I think if there is one and he’s aware of what you’re up to he’s nothing but proud and happy of his mom. I could imagine him seeing you take care of Jumby the way you took care of him and being so very happy that another boy gets to enjoy your love. He would understand. If he knows, I am confident of that much. You raised him right, and he’d understand.
SugarShok
Tanis,
Thank you for sharing this. Please allow yourself and your children to feel whatever you are feeling honestly with each other. Jumby will grow to understand that your grief at your loss does not detract from your joy that he is in the world. In these ways he becomes a full partner in the emotional life of your family. I’m sending hugs and good wishes to you all.
Renee
P.S. I’m sure Jumby will have a wonderful day. And remember, he even gets two special days! One birthday and one “coming home” day a day to celebrate his entry into your family!
Random
“Death leaves a heartache no one can heal, love leaves a memory no one can steal.”
baltimoregal
My heart actually ached reading this. I can’t imagine how this day will ever easy for you but I do know that, luckily, days go by.
Joanna Ciolek
You are amazingly strong Tanis. May this day become easier to bear for you and your family with each and every new year. Shale and Jumby are in all our hearts. Such beautiful boys. They are trully lucky to have a mommy like you!
Jamie
I have no words…. a heart string pulling post…. I wish you all the best!